The battle ends: special request granted for gravel mining in LaPorte

gravel pit story

At the close of a long and impassioned hearing at the Larimer County Courthouse on Monday, November 19, Larimer County Commissioners Steve Johnson, Tom Donnelly and interim commissioner Sean Dougherty all agreed. Loveland Ready Mix had met all the technical requirements, including agreement to 43 added conditions, to their request for a special review allowing them to commence mining operations at the Knox Gravel Pit in LaPorte. LRM owns 123 acres of gravel-rich land adjacent to the town of LaPorte and close to the Poudre River.

Yet, despite agreeing with the other commissioners that LRM had met all the technical requirements, Larimer County Commission chairman Steve Johnson voted to deny the special review.

“I had to ask myself if I would want to live in LaPorte with the mine there,” he said. He concluded that not enough evidence had been provided for him to see the project as compatible with the existing community. He voted no. The special review request passed 2-1. Senior Larimer County Planner Rob Helmick said that operations could begin as early as the summer of 2019.

Thus ended a nearly two-year all-out effort by the citizens of LaPorte to prevent a mining operation scheduled to last as long as 12 years. Over and over, in hearings, on signs, in speeches, in meetings, on Facebook and in signing petitions, the community came together to preserve the rural nature of their community. They never gave up, appearing in force on Monday night although the handwriting was on the wall. The fact that the Larimer County Planning Commission had earlier voted in favor of LRM’s request, could not dampen their hopes to see the review defeated by the Larimer County Commissioners who had the final word.

LaPorte residents at the start of the hearing

Because of the citizens’ continuing efforts, LRM has agreed to limit noise levels, truck traffic, hours of operation and to monitor air quality and ground water levels. They will reclaim mined land as they complete mining in an area and have agreed to the construction of berms and the planting of trees, grasses and bushes on the land.

It was after 10:30 p.m. when the final voice vote was taken. Some of the audience had gone home. Those who remained left their seats and departed quietly. LRM owners Stephanie Fancher-English and Brad Fancher were quiet also, putting their heads together in a small group at the front of the room, relieved, at the end of a long road, to know that their mining operations will become a reality.




Support Northern Colorado Journalism

Show your support for North Forty News by helping us produce more content. It's a kind and simple gesture that will help us continue to bring more content to you.

BONUS - Donors get a link in their receipt to sign up for our once-per-week instant text messaging alert. Get your e-copy of North Forty News the moment it is released!

Click to Donate


  1. This is not only About Gravel Mining! The permanate structure of a Concrete Batch Plant & Aggregate Crush creating a severe impact on Environment, Traffic Safety, Health and Lifestyle.

  2. Not a big surprise the gravel pit was approved. There were public hearings on the new stadium in Fort Collins and it went through pretty easily.
    The old saw of “you can’t fight city hall” has been around for a long time and is still true today. Call me cynical if you like, but we never stood a chance. This was a done deal from day one.
    Thanks Steve for listening to the residents of LaPorte. I for one appreciate your vote.

Comments are closed.