10 Perfect Pies from Northern Colorado Bakers

By Blaine Howerton | Northfortynews.com

As the holiday season approaches, there’s no better time to indulge in the comforting embrace of a homemade pie.

Northern Colorado boasts a vibrant community of bakers who have perfected their craft, offering a delightful array of pies that cater to every palate.

There are so many great bakeries in Northern Colorado it was hard to narrow it down to ten!

Indeed, other great pie shops are not included here.

Here is my list, each accompanied by insights:

1. SALTED CARAMEL APPLE PIE

Me Oh My Pie in LaPorte is a charming local bakery known for its homemade, small-batch pies that delight the taste buds of Northern Colorado residents. Their most popular creation, the Salted Caramel Apple Pie, is a fan favorite, featuring tender, cinnamon-spiced apples layered with rich caramel and a hint of sea salt, all nestled in a perfectly flaky, golden crust. This cozy spot is a must-visit for pie lovers and anyone seeking a sweet slice of comfort in the heart of LaPorte.

2. CHOCOLATE SILK PIE

Fiona’s Deli in Fort Collins is a beloved spot for fresh, flavorful meals and decadent desserts. One of their standout offerings is the Chocolate Silk Pie, a rich and velvety creation that’s a favorite among chocolate lovers. This indulgent pie features a silky smooth chocolate filling, topped with a cloud of whipped cream and chocolate shavings, all nestled in a buttery, flaky crust. Perfect as the sweet finale to a meal or a treat on its own, Fiona’s Chocolate Silk Pie is a must-try for anyone with a love for chocolate and a taste for quality.

3. BOURBON PECAN PIE

Buttermilk Bakery in Fort Collins is a beloved neighborhood gem celebrated for its artisanal baked goods and cozy atmosphere. Among their standout offerings is the Bourbon Pecan Pie, a crowd favorite that balances rich, buttery pecans with a hint of bourbon for a perfect blend of sweetness and warmth. Nestled in a tender, flaky crust, this pie embodies the bakery’s dedication to using high-quality ingredients and classic recipes with a modern twist, making it a must-try treat in Fort Collins.

4. CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE

Fiona’s Deli in Fort Collins is a cherished local spot known for its fresh, flavorful offerings and welcoming ambiance. While they excel in savory delights, their dessert selection shines, with the Chocolate Cream Pie being a standout favorite. This luscious pie features a silky chocolate filling topped with fluffy whipped cream and a sprinkle of chocolate shavings, all cradled in a buttery crust. It’s a decadent treat that keeps customers coming back for more, cementing Fiona’s reputation as a go-to for both hearty meals and indulgent desserts.

5. COCONUT CREAM PIE

Ginger and Baker in Fort Collins is a culinary hotspot blending a modern vibe with a love for timeless comfort food. Known for its charming café and pie shop, their signature Coconut Cream Pie is a must-try. This delectable treat features a creamy coconut custard filling, a perfectly crisp crust, and a generous topping of whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes. With its commitment to quality and innovation, Ginger and Baker has become a local favorite for everything from brunch to dessert, and their pies are the heart of the experience.

6. CHERRY PIE

Johnson’s Corner in Johnstown is a legendary stop for locals and travelers alike, renowned for its comforting diner-style meals and award-winning baked goods. While their cinnamon rolls are iconic, their Cherry Pie steals the show for pie lovers. Bursting with tart cherries and nestled in a flaky, golden crust, this pie has become a favorite among regulars and first-timers.

Since 1952, Johnson’s Corner has been a must-visit for those seeking a slice of Colorado history and delicious homemade treats.

7. PEANUT BUTTER PIE

Fat Albert’s Restaurant in Greeley used to be a cozy spot celebrated for its hearty homestyle meals and welcoming atmosphere. Unfortunately, it closed last year. Among its standout desserts, the Peanut Butter Pie is a local favorite, featuring a creamy, rich peanut butter filling topped with whipped cream and drizzled with chocolate. Perfectly balanced between indulgence and comfort, this pie has become a must-try for anyone visiting Fat Albert’s. This could be your last chance, because Fat Alberts is offering a limited selection of their pies for this Thanksgiving!

8. CLASSIC APPLE PIE

The Cakery in Wellington is a delightful bakery known for its creative and beautifully crafted sweet treats. While they’re most celebrated for their gourmet cupcakes and custom cakes, their seasonal pies are a hidden gem. Among the favorites is their classic Apple Pie, featuring tender, cinnamon-spiced apples baked to perfection in a buttery, flaky crust. As a beloved local spot, The Cakery continues to charm Wellington residents with its commitment to quality and creativity in every dessert they create.

9. CHERRY PIE

Colorado Cherry Company, located Loveland, is a fourth-generation family-owned business renowned for its cherry pies and other fruit-based desserts. Their signature Cherry Pie, made with fresh, locally sourced cherries and a flaky, golden crust, has garnered widespread acclaim and was voted “Best Pie” in Colorado Country Life Magazine’s Readers’ Choice Awards.

10. PUMPKIN PIE

Little Bird Bakeshop, located at 613 S. College Ave. in Fort Collins, Colorado, is a 100% from-scratch bakery known for its freshly baked pastries, light breakfast and lunch options, and handcrafted beverages.  Among their popular offerings is the Pumpkin Pie, made with house-roasted locally grown organic pumpkin, Morning Fresh dairy, Jodar Farms eggs, Madagascar vanilla, and warm spices, all baked in an all-butter pastry crust.

These pies represent the rich culinary talent found in Northern Colorado.

These local bakers offer recipes and creations that are sure to delight!

Support your local bakeries and enjoy a slice (or two) of these delectable pies this season.

I’ll buy you a slice, if you buy me another!