by Blaine Howerton | NorthFortyNews.com
Fort Collins has no shortage of great restaurants, but when it comes to blending old-world Italian charm with top-tier steakhouse dining, RARE Italian stands out. Located in the heart of Old Town, this locally loved gem serves up an experience rooted in tradition, hospitality, and, of course, unforgettable food.
A Slice of Italy in Old Town
Walking into RARE Italian feels like stepping into a classic European eatery, with warm lighting, rich wood accents, and an inviting atmosphere. Inspired by the steakhouses of Italy, the restaurant takes pride in sourcing high-quality, dry-aged meats and fresh, house-made pastas.
What makes RARE truly special is its on-site dry-aging program—one of the only of its kind in Northern Colorado. Their 55-day dry-aged steaks develop deep, complex flavors that set them apart from anything else in town. Whether you’re ordering a bone-in ribeye or the Florentine-style porterhouse, expect a perfectly seared, tender, and flavorful cut.
Handmade Pasta & Authentic Italian Classics
While the steaks are the stars of the show, the pasta dishes at RARE are just as impressive. Everything is made from scratch, using traditional techniques that bring the flavors of Italy to life.
- House-Made Ricotta Gnocchi – A creamy, dreamy dish that melts in your mouth.
- Tagliatelle Bolognese – A slow-cooked, hearty classic that tastes like it came straight from a Tuscan kitchen.
- Squid Ink Spaghetti – A briny, bold seafood lover’s delight.
Pair any dish with a glass of hand-selected Italian wine, and you’ve got a meal to remember.
A Place for Every Occasion
Whether you’re celebrating a special night out or just craving an expertly cooked steak, RARE Italian delivers. The service is top-notch, with a staff that’s both knowledgeable and passionate about food. If you’re looking for a more intimate experience, the restaurant also offers a chef’s table experience, where you can get a behind-the-scenes look at their culinary craftsmanship.
Plan Your Visit
Location: 101 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO
Hours: Monday–Sunday, 4 PM – 9 PM (10 PM on Fridays & Saturdays)
rareitalian.com
For those who appreciate great food, great service, and an atmosphere that feels both elegant and comfortable, RARE Italian is a must-visit in Fort Collins.
Looking for more top eats in Northern Colorado? Check out our first article in the Top Eats series featuring 15 Best Restaurants in Fort Collins at northfortynews.com and stay tuned for the next feature!